Topic: Life
I'm not sure where to begin with this, so I suppose I'll just dive in.
Recently, I've seen a great deal of antagonism directed towards Tony Powell in video comments and video responses on YouTube.
I had no exposure to the video blogs made by Powell (commonly known on YouTube as Tony48219) until the recent tragedy in which he took a young woman's life and his own at a Michigan College. But since that sad event, I daily come across new clips of his now, notorious videos.
Powell, though his most recent channel has been stripped of his video content, had a lengthy documented history in where he espoused his intolerance towards Atheism and modern feminism, and touted his own version of Fundamentalist Christianity most of which was inspired by the mythology of the Old Testament.
It would be easy to blame Christianity or religion in general for Powell's actions on April 10th and use it as a platform in support of our own differing views. I mean, we Pagans often have more than one bone to pick with Fundamentalist and Evangelical Christians. Atheists too, in so far as the onslaught of ideological attacks that are thrown their direction by Christians daily on YouTube (just look up the name VenomFangX sometime).
Lets not confuse our personal issues in regards to Christianity with the reality that Anthony Powell had suffered from manic depression (also known as Bipolar Disorder) since childhood. A condition that causes unusual changes in the person’s mood, energy, and ability to function. A condition that Powell, himself, refused to acknowledge and refused to take medication for.
This condition, however, is not solely to blame as I have personally known several people who deal with manic depression, some more severe than others and none of them have the capacity to take the life of another human being, with or without medication.
I believe there are far more factors to Powell killing 20 year old Asia McGowan that are far more complex than his archaic views of Christianity, women or his manic depression. Most of which will undoubtedly never be discovered.
We will never know the real history of Anthony Powell, as we all keep secrets... even from our parents, family and friends. Most of which are painful and fill us with shame. Events that have nothing to do with religion, politics or science.
This does not excuse his actions. Nothing excuses the act of murdering an innocent life.
I suppose the point I am trying to make here is that Anthony Powell was a unique individual, not a generic example that can be applied to Christianity or mental illness. Implying that he killed Asia McGown because he was Christian or religious, is like saying "All people with a mental illness are potential killers". It is a dangerous and unfair generalization.
Just my thoughts.
Brightest blessings.
Updated: Tuesday, 27 October 2009 7:02 PM
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post